Robinson Crusoe: Essay Q&A

1. How does Robinson Crusoes conversation with his father at the beginning of the book relate to the novels overarching concern with “providence” or fate?
Crusoes conversation with his father introduces the question of whether one should be content with ones given lot in life. Although the bourgeois would not emerge as the predominant social class until the mid- to late-19th century, Defoes work is clearly preoccupied with the middle class station, influence, and privilege. Crusoes father attempts to impress upon him the advantages of being born into the middle class relatively comfortable existence. Crusoe, however, by his own admission, is driven by a compulsion to seek adventure; not even the unfortunate case of his elder brother, who was killed in “the Low Country Wars” (that is, conflicts in The Netherlands, Belgium, and Luxembourg), can dissuade Crusoe from going to sea. And although the narrator insists throughout the text that his decision to do so was a mistake-note, for instance, the many occasions on which Crusoe bewails the “evil influence which carryed me first away from my Fathers House”-readers may justly wonder how seriously this judgment should be received. After all, were it not for that “evil influence,” neither Crusoe nor, of course, his creator Defoe would have a tale to tell! This conversation thus poses the question of whether a safe and comfortable life (such as that open the socio-economic stratum in which Crusoe was born) is, in fact, to be preferred to a life in which, for good or for ill, one is the maker of ones own fortune (both economic and otherwise). Throughout the rest of the novel, we will see Crusoe making his own life-especially, of course, on the island-and our ultimate impression of who is “in the right” in this exchange between Crusoe and his father will depend on how we judge the life that Crusoe establishes, and the character that he becomes.
2. How is Crusoes shipwreck upon the island a “baptismal” experience? How does this symbolism connect with larger thematic concerns of the novel?
The symbolic value of water in the section about the shipwreck should not be overlooked. As Thomas C. Foster points out, in literature, “weather is never just weather.” The sea storms may be taken (whether Defoe intended them as such or not) as symbols of the “storms” within Crusoe, as he knows he is undertaking a voyage he does not need to undertake. Furthermore, the vividly described shipwreck scene itself evokes baptismal imagery and associations; as Foster claims about water in literature, submersion and emergence generally points to baptism-not necessarily the literal Christian sacrament, but rather the experience of rebirth to which it points. Crusoe himself speaks more than once of his emergence from the sea onto the island as his “Deliverance,” a word with religious and baptismal overtones. He states, “I was now landed, and safe on Shore, and began to look up and thank God that my Life was savd.” Readers are thus prepared to see how, if at all, Crusoe has been “reborn” through his “baptism” in the hurricane. He has been delivered from death through water. How will he shape-or how will he be shaped by-his “new” life? The rest of the novel explores the answers to these questions.
3. Before his shipwreck, Crusoe has the services of a boy named Xury; afterward, he has the services of “my man Friday.” Before his shipwreck, Crusoe had an estranged relationship with his father; afterward, he witnesses the affectionate reunion of Friday with Fridays father. How do these parallels develop the thematic concerns of Robinson Crusoe?
The parallels are certainly not accidental. The first parallel, between Xury and Friday, may serve to establish that Crusoe does not actually change much as a character throughout the course of the book (in this writers judgment-other readers may of course disagree!). Crusoe professes affection for both Xury and Friday, but ultimately seems to value them both only in a utilitarian way: how can they serve him? The parallel between Crusoes failed relationship to his father and Fridays loving relationship to his may further point out the negative character flaws of Crusoe. The Puritan society in which Defoe wrote his text would have valued the biblical injunction to “honor thy father and mother,” and Crusoe broke this commandment in leaving Hull to seek adventure at sea. Crusoe acknowledges this, of course-during much of his exile, he regards his isolation as punishment for this prideful sin-but he is prevented from making amends with his father because his father has died by the time he, Crusoe, returns to England. Friday, on the other hand, has never become estranged from his father. For all his supposed “savagery,” then, Friday has achieved something the “civilized” Crusoe has not: a continued, close, affectionate relationship with his father.
4. Discuss the significance of Crusoes discovery of another humans footprint in terms of the novels larger thematic concerns
The discovery of the footprint is one of the most dramatic turn of events in Crusoes narrative, and it serves as the occasion for some further reflections upon Crusoes situation and life. For example, note how Crusoe speaks of returning to his “Castle, for so I think I calld it ever after this,” upon discovering the footprint. We have seen before how Crusoe has fancied himself as monarch of the island; now, however, such terminology as “castle” acquires an ironic edge: if he is not alone on the island, he is perhaps not the “sovereign” he imagines himself to be. Furthermore, we see illustrated in Crusoes reactions how, in his own words, “Fear banish[es] all. religious Hope.” Since Crusoes faith in the benign nature of Providence will be strengthened by the end of this segment of the text, we can perhaps take the incident as a narrative homily on 1 John 4:18: “There is no fear in love, but perfect love casts out fear.” Once Crusoe comes to a fuller “love,” or at the least trust, in Gods goodness by the end of this section, he no longer fears the maker of the footprint-at least not as much as he initially did! We also learn from Crusoe how fear is the enemy of reason, and watch Crusoe struggle to bring reason to bear to the situation-possibly a struggle we can construe as his continued assertion of “civilization” in the face of “savagery”-or “humane” versus “inhumane,” to use Crusoes own terms-a recurring thematic dichotomy in the text.
5. Is the Christian faith a positive or negative force within Robinson Crusoe?
Although Christian faith helps Crusoe through many difficult and dark hours on the island, the text also provides evidence that the same faith has a potentially darker edge. Note how, for example, Crusoe continues to see himself explicitly as an agent of God: “I would only go and place my self near them. and that I would act as God should direct.” As another example, note that Crusoe shares bread and wine with the freed Spaniard-perhaps a parody of the Christian Eucharist (Mass). Religion, as students of history are aware, can be a savage force in its service of “civilization,” and readers of Crusoes narrative must determine the extent to which the protagonist truly sees himself as acting “in the Name of God”-the phrase may be far more than a casual turn of speech, and far more dangerous: Readers will not fail to note the triumphant language Crusoe uses to describe his situation once all the prisoners have been freed: “I was absolute Lord and Lawgiver: they all owed their Lives to me.” Crusoe-once more, as Adam before him-is committing the sin of hubris. He has replaced God in his own eyes. Perhaps most telling is the point at which Crusoe claims he has “set a Table there for them”-a direct and seemingly inescapable allusion to his own earlier, more humble acknowledgment that only God can “set a table in the wilderness.” Upon undertaking the mission to liberate the other Spaniards, Crusoe takes on the aspect of some sort of avenger, reserving to himself the right to mete out life and death. Is he the picture of a civilized man? Whether Defoe intended his text to be interpreted in this skeptical way, the raw materials for such a reading are present and ought not be ignored.